SANTO DOMINGO, República Dominicana.-El embajador Hans Hertell y el embajador Robert Fannin relatan en los informes enviados al Departamento de Estado, y revelados por Wikileaks, que el presidente Leonel Fernández les dijo que las Fuerzas Armadas de República Dominicana eran una institución “corrupta”, pero que él creía que si destituía a los jefes militares corruptos podría ser depuesto como gobernante.
La embajada norteamericana le expresó al presidente Fernández preocupación por los siguientes altos oficiales militares: Manuel de Jesús Florentino y Florentino, Pedro Peña Antonio, Héctor Medina Medina, Rafael Bencosme Candelier y José Muñoz Monción. A esos oficiales el gobierno de Estados Unidos no los quería en cargos importantes en las instituciones militares u otras áreas del Estado dominicano.
A tal punto que uno de los cables de la Embajada de los Estados Unidos, expresa:
“La embajada trajo a colación los problemas con el Departamento Nacional de Inteligencia (DNI) bajo el liderazgo del general retirado Manuel de Jesús Florentino y Florentino y llevó a cabo una franca conversación sobre la competencia e integridad de Florentino, así como informaciones que vinculan a Florentino con Paulino (Quirino Ernesto Paulino Castillo, el narcotraficante). El Presidente (Leonel Fernández) señaló que durante su primer mandato, Florentino había sido Secretario de las Fuerzas Armadas y que había encabezado la guardia presidencial también. Fernández lo consideraba un oficial serio y correcto y dijo que no le conocía asociación a Florentino con el narcotráfico. El Presidente pareció aceptar los argumentos de la embajada, sin embargo, estuvo de acuerdo en sacar a Florentino pronto, en un momento menos volátil políticamente, y pidió consejo de la embajada sobre su reemplazo”.
"Fernández dijo que se sobreentiende que los militares de alto rango a menudo toman el 10% de los recursos que pasan por sus manos como “comisión”, añadiendo que las fuerzas armadas es una institución corrupta. Dijo que si se movía demasiado rápido cancelando a los oficiales corruptos, su propia posición estaría en peligro”
Asimismo, señala: “El Mayor General Florentino Florentino, un individuo sobre el cual la Misión (la embajada de EE.UU) tiene gran preocupación en cuanto a la actividad ilegal, fue nombrado jefe de la Dirección de Desarrollo Fronterizo, donde las oportunidades para la corrupción relacionada con la frontera haitiana son significativas”.
En las conversaciones sostenidas entre el embajador Hans Hertell y el presidente Leonel Fernández, el representante del gobierno norteamericano le habría expresado al gobernante dominicano que “tres posibles ascensos” provocaban “seria preocupación para EUA”, y correspondían al general Héctor Medina Medina, que sonaba para Ministro de las Fuerzas Armadas; el general Rafael Bencosme Candelier, que sonaba como Jefe de la Policía; y José Muñoz Monción, almirante retirado, como Jefe de Estado Mayor de la Marina.
La embajada de EE.UU saluda que esos nombramientos no se materializaron, pero agrega:
“Sin embargo, la Misión mantiene su preocupación en cuanto a los servicios de seguridad: el Presidente” confirmó” a Medina Medina en su actual posición como Jefe del Cuerpo de Ayudantes Militares (CAM), donde él continuará teniendo una poderosa influencia sobre las decisiones militares del Presidente (particularmente en lo que concierne al personal). Muñoz Monción fue nombrado comandante de la Base Naval de Las Calderas, ubicada en una región importante en la actividad de tráfico de drogas. Los recursos del país anfitrión establecidos en Las Calderas son los que deben actuar frente a las entregas de drogas por mar provenientes de Suramérica. El Mayor General Florentino Florentino, un individuo sobre el cual la Misión tiene gran preocupación en cuanto a la actividad ilegal (Ref D) fue nombrado jefe de la Dirección de Desarrollo Fronterizo, donde las oportunidades para la corrupción relacionada con la frontera haitiana son significativas”.
Agrega que en la Dirección Nacional de Inteligencia, el cooperador director Sigfrido Pared Pérez fue sustituido por el mayor general Ramón Aquino García, “cuyo récord es más neutral”.
“Como una nota potencialmente más positiva, Bencosme Candelier fue llevado como jefe de la Autoridad Metropolitana de Transporte (AMET), donde supuestamente tendrá menos oportunidades para las actividades nefarias” (Nota de Acento.com.do: nefarias significa abominables, nefastas, muy malas).
Más sobre los militares y la corrupción
Según uno de los cables enviados por los embajadores de Estados Unidos, el presidente Fernández le habría comentado al embajador estadounidense que aunque apreciaba a los militares, porque si había algo que funcionaba en la República Dominicana, era las Fuerzas Armadas, por su disciplina y respeto a la jerarquía, y porque son orgullosos de su posición.
No obstante, el diplomático afirma en su cable:
“Comentando sobre las fuerzas armadas, Fernández dijo que se sobreentiende que los militares de alto rango a menudo toman el 10% de los recursos que pasan por sus manos como “comisión”, añadiendo que las fuerzas armadas es una institución corrupta. Dijo que si se movía demasiado rápido cancelando a los oficiales corruptos, su propia posición estaría en peligro”.
Asimismo, dijo que un logro importante importante de su gobierno había sido el retiro forzoso de 100 generales desde que retornara al poder el 16 de agosto de 2004, y que había otros 100 generales más que debían ser relevados de sus cargos.
De acuerdo con el cable de la embajada de Estados Unidos, el presidente Fernández señaló que (Hipólito) Mejía le tenía aprecio a los militares y mantenía a miembros de su seguridad en uniforme mientras que él prefiere que su seguridad vista de civil.
Estas informaciones están contenidas en tres de los más de 2 mil cables de la embajada estadounidense en Santo Domingo, que fueron obtenidos por el sitio en Internet Wikileaks, que a su vez los cedió al grupo de comunicación SIN, que preside Fernando Hasbún, para sus programas El Informe con Alicia Ortega, Noticias SIN y El Despertador. El grupo SIN los cedió a Acento.com.do, gracias a una alianza estratégica. Los cables citados este lunes están fechados el 11 de febrero de 2005, el 6 de mayo de 2005 y 27 de agosto 2008, y fueron enviados por Hans Hertell y por su sucesor Robert Fannin.
Este lunes los cables fueron difundidos y analizados tanto en El Despertador con Alicia Ortega, como en Noticias SIN, por Antena Latina, canal 7.
WIKILEAKS
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Dirigentes del PRD no reaccionan ante el cable de Hans Hertell (100%)
- Noticias – Jorge Subero Isa respaldó en enero las publicaciones de Wikileaks (95%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Céspedes niega protegiera narcotraficantes como dijo Hertell (90%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Sólo Domínguez Brito y Pina han salido bien parados en cables de EE.UU (90%)
- Noticias – Isa y Almánzar dicen Subero es "chivato del imperio” con “complejo de Guacanagarix” (90%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Felucho expresa dudas, porque en su caso fue “una mentira grosera” (85%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Cardenal dice que no le da importancia a cables de Hertell (80%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: “Céspedes ha ayudado y actuado en connivencia con el narcotráfico" (75%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Jaime David dice “hay embajadores que han venido a chantajear” (75%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Fiscales y jueces callan; abogados piden una investigación (75%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Guerrero advierte ocultar ahora cables EE.UU crearía una crisis en RD (70%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: EEUU pidió quitar a Gómez Mazara, Miguel Vásquez, Víctor Céspedes y a Castellanos (70%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Fiscal dice cables EE.UU sobre Suprema Corte son “falaces y mentirosos” (65%)
- Noticias – Los cables de Wikileaks y la transparencia (55%)
- Noticias – Subero: hay “inexactitudes” en cable Wikileaks; Luciano llora y jura no es corrupto (50%)
- Blog – Wikileaks: consecuencias sin consecuencias (50%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Vincho descalifica a Hertell, y niega que pudiera quitar a Subero (45%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Luciano estaría metido en corrupción y favorecería acusados Baninter (35%)
- Noticias – Subero Isa y Luciano Pichardo ante la presunción de inocencia (35%)
- Noticias – WikiLeaks confirma EEUU violó los derechos y abusó de presos en Guantánamo (35%)
- Noticias – Hipólito califica de "graves" las revelaciones de Wikileaks sobre corrupción en SCJ (35%)
- Noticias – Reinaldo Pared y Victor Gómez admiten compraron apartamentos a narco (25%)
- Noticias – Jaime David "Los cables de Wikileaks son una degradación de los sistemas de comunicación de EE.UU"(20%)
- Noticias – Wikileaks: Ramón Almánzar "nuestros funcionarios tienen complejo de Guacanagarix" (20%)
- Wikileaks República Dominicana – Wikileaks República Dominicana (20%)
- Noticias – ¿Qué opina usted acerca de los cables de Wikileaks que envuelven a miembros de la SCJ? (20%)
- Wikileaks – Wikileaks (20%)
- Blog – Wikileaks y credibilidad de la Justicia (15%)
- Blog – Wikileaks y los Mencionados (15%)
- Noticias – Subero: hay “inexactitudes” en cable Wikileaks; Luciano llora y jura no es corrupto (15%)
- Noticias – Vinculan al embajador de Colombia en RD con paramilitares (15%)
- Noticias – Narciso Isa Conde: Subero es "chivato del imperio" (10%)
Los cables en inglés:
26895 11 de febrero, 2005
S E C R E T SECTION 01 OF 03 SANTO DOMINGO 000709
SIPDIS
STATE FOR WHA, WHA/CAR, WHA/EPSC, INL; NSC FOR SHANNON AND
MADISON; TREASURY FOR OASIA-LAMONICA; USTR FOR MALITO
E.O. 12958: DECL: 02/09/2015
TAGS: EFIN, KIPR, ETRD, DR
SUBJECT: DOMINICAN PRESIDENT ON BROADCAST PIRACY, LAW
ENFORCEMENT REFORM, EXTRADITION AND ECONOMIC PROGRAM
Classified By: DCM LKUBISKE. Reason 1.4 (b) and (d).
1. (C) Summary. Dominican President Leonel Fernandez
discussed the Dominican economy, CAFTA, broadcast piracy,
Haiti and police and intelligence reform during a February 2
meeting with the Ambassador. Fernandez believes the new IMF
Standby Agreement is as important for creating confidence as
it is for bringing stability to the country. He said that
his government is committed to educating the public on CAFTA,
an agreement still misunderstood by much of the country. He
promised to look into the continuing problem of television
broadcast piracy. Fernandez gave details regarding planned
changes in the National Directorate of Intelligence and said
that he would accept Embassy information to assist in
cleaning up the corrupt police force. He said that he would
speak with the Dominican Ambassador to Haiti regarding his
behavior, and acknowledged the importance of a sensitive
extradition case now underway. End summary.
2. (SBU) In a February 2 meeting, the Ambassador
congratulated President Fernandez on completion of the IMF
Standby Agreement, announced January 31. Fernandez noted
that the agreement is as important for creating confidence as
it is for bringing economic stability. He believes it vital
for Dominicans to understand that the Standby agreement is
not creating new austerity, but that his government began
taking the current cost-cutting measures immediately after
taking office last August. &I think that the worst of the
crisis has passed,8 he said.
3. (C) The Ambassador noted that the quasi-fiscal deficit is
a serious and persistent problem. Fernandez said that yes,
the deficit is real, but argued that the peso,s appreciation
has made it a smaller problem than it was before. He
reported that a committee had been formed with
representatives from the Attorney General,s Office, Central
Bank, and the Banking Superintendent to decide how to
liquidate Baninter debt. Fernndez added that the proceeds
from collections will be used to reduce the deficit, and
pointed out that this year government deficit spending is .7%
and that the 2006 target is to eliminate the deficit
completely. Any surplus in 2006 would be applied to reduce
the quasi-fiscal deficit.
CAFTA and IPR
4. (C) The Ambassador mentioned the recent meeting of foreign
ministers in Central America regarding CAFTA and their
universal support for ratification. Fernandez asked when the
United States expected to ratify. The Ambassador responded
that ratification is moving forward in the United States
already and that the Dominican Republic should proceed as
soon as possible. Fernandez noted that Chile has done
exceptionally well and benefitted under its bilateral free
trade agreement with the United States. He was conversant
with Chile’s export figures and saw the country,s free trade
relations with the United States under NAFTA as responsible
for the country,s strong economic performance, adding that
the Dominican Republic,s proximity to the United States
should allow for even greater benefits here. Fernandez said
that he wants to organize a daylong program at his Global
Foundation for Democracy and Development (www.funglode.org)
to help explain and discuss CAFTA. He thinks that there is
still much misunderstanding about the agreement and that a
discussion by Dominican senators, business leaders and
economists would lead to greater public understanding of the
benefits of CAFTA. He hopes that one or two people from USTR
could speak at this event.
5. (C) The Ambassador incicated the U.S. Government,s desire
to see an end to television broadcast piracy and noted that
U.S. Representative Katherine Harris has expressed her
concern about the broadcast piracy problem in the Dominican
Republic and will soon be sending Fernandez a letter
documenting her interest. The Ambassador said that
television broadcast piracy remains a serious problem here
and that despite a court case late last year against the
major Dominican station Telemicro, independent state action
to stop the problem is urgently needed. He reminded
Fernandez of his desire to develop the film industry here and
to organize a film festival in the future to promote the
industry, noting that these plans will not advance if piracy
continues. The Ambassador told Fernandez that the Motion
Picture Association of America (MPAA) has asked for a review
of the Dominican Republic,s GSP status based on the
continuing problem. Fernandez asked if CAFTA would not make
GSP redundant. The DCM noted that broadcast piracy will
continue to be a problem in any number of contexts, including
CAFTA ratification, if not cleaned up.
6. (C) Fernandez said that he knew that Telemicro had
broadcast &new8 (pirated) movies in the past, but thought
that the problem had been resolved. He said that he would
check into the issue, adding in English, &I’ve got the
message.8 Continuing with the theme of IPR enforcement
related to movies, Fernandez mentioned that he had argued
with the head of the National Copyright Office (ONDA)
recently for having conducted a raid on a prominent local
video store. He noted that the video rental business has no
interest in pirated products and that these &legitimate8
stores are against piracy. (Note: We have heard several
versions of the raid story; and one includes the use of
presidential police to call off ONDA during the raid. The
issue of video stores is murky, involving legitimately
purchased products created for the U.S. market being sold
here, circumventing the regional code protocols set up by
major studios. End note.)
Paulino–Drugs
7. (C ) Speaking of the recent arrest of retired Captain
Quirino Paulino Castillo for narcotrafficking, Fernandez said
that the case had taken the country by surprise. Fernandez
commented that it is often impossible to know what a person
is truly like. During his campaign the president personally
heard very positive comments about Paulino. He noted that he
hopes for Paulino,s prompt extradition without mishaps. He
promised to try to ensure adequate security for Paulino while
his extradition request is pending a Supreme Court decision.
Concerns about Dominican Intelligence Chief
8. (S) The Embassy raised problems with the National
Intelligence Directorate (DNI) under the leadership of
Retired General Manuel de Jesus Florentino y Florentino, and
led a frank discussion concerning questions about
Florentino,s competence and personal integrity, as well as
information linking Florentino to Paulino. The President
noted that during his first term Florentino had served as his
Secretary of the Armed Forces and had headed the presidential
SIPDIS
security guard as well. Fernandez had seen him as a serious,
and &correct8 officer and said that he had not known of any
association by Florentino with narcotrafficking. The
president seemed to acknowledge Embassy arguments, however
and agreed to remove Florentino &soon8 at a less
politically volatile moment, and sought Embassy input on his
replacement.
Crime and Corruption
9. (C ) Commenting on the military, Fernandez said that it is
understood that high-ranking military staff members routinely
take 10% of resources that passes through their hands as a
"commission,8 adding &the military is a corrupt
institution.8 He said that if he moved too fast in firing
corrupt officers, his own position would be in jeopardy. He
noted that Mejia was fond of the military and kept his guards
dressed in uniform while Fernandez prefers civilian clothing
for his guards. Fernandez considered it a significant
achievement to have forced retirement of 100 generals since
taking office. He commented that this still leaves 100 more
who should be relieved. On the other hand, he said, "if one
thing works in the Dominican Republic, it,s the military,8
— indicating that the military is disciplined, and
hierarchical, and proud of position.
10. (C) Fernandez said one of his government,s priorities
is dealing with crime and an important element is cleaning up
the police force. Immediately after his inauguration, he
noted, Dominicans just wanted him to strengthen the peso, but
now all they want is a lower crime rate. Fernandez asked
for Embassy ideas on combating police corruption and said
that he was receiving advice from the New York City Police
Department, the NYPD, New Jersey State Police, and John Jay
College of Criminal Justice of the City University of New
York, and had invited the Bogota (Colombia) police chief to
help improve training of the Dominican police force. Embassy
NAS Officer noted that training and equipping the police
force is vital, but narcotics-related corruption at the
highest levels of the police force must also be addressed.
Fernandez said that he would fire corrupt police officers
when provided with evidence and asked for Embassy,s help in
obtaining this. The Ambassador offered to provide additional
details regarding known corrupt officials.
Haiti
11. (S) As a followup to previous discussions between the
Ambassador and President Fernandez regarding Haiti, the
Ambassador referred to rumors that Dominican Ambassador to
Haiti Jose Serulle Ramia was not being entirely faithful to
Dominican policy guidelines. Fernandez replied that he had
chosen Serulle for this position because he belongs to a
respected family and is serious, educated, honest, and
trusted, and fluent in French and Creole and thus a fitting
representative for the Dominican Republic. However,
Fernandez conceded, Serulle, like others in his family, is a
&little crazy8 and very emotional, and commented only half
in jest that he would not be surprised if Serulle considered
himself a viable candidate for the presidency of Haiti.
Fernandez stated categorically that he understands that
Serulle is meeting in a "leadership role" with all sectors of
Haitian society, including the opposition, — which,
according to Fernandez, "is not his job." Fernandez promised
to rein in Serulle. He emphasized that the Dominican
Government recognizes the Haitian Interim Government (IGOH).
He said that he believes his government has a responsibility
to help Haiti, since Haiti,s situation affects both sides of
the border. (Note: Foreign Minister Carlos Morales
Troncoso, in comments to the Ambassador on February 7, called
Serulle &useless8 and &crazy8 and said he would be
removed within the next two weeks. Septel reports details of
that meeting. End note.)
SECRET
SIPDIS
HERTELL
32129 6 de mayo , 2005
C O N F I D E N T I A L SECTION 01 OF 03 SANTO DOMINGO 002576
SIPDIS
NSC FOR SHANNON; DEPT FOR S/S, WHA, WHA/CAR, EB,
EB/TPP/BTA/EWH; TREASURY FOR DO:N LEE, R TOLOUI, L CARTER;
SECDEF FOR OSD; SOUTHCOM ALSO FOR POLAD
E.O. 12958: DECL: 05/05/2015
TAGS: PREL, OVIP, ETRD, DR
SUBJECT: POLICY POINTS; WASHINGTON VISIT OF DOMINICAN
PRESIDENT LEONEL FERNANDEZ, MAY 11-12
Classified By: Ambassador Hans H. Hertell. Reason: 1.4 (b) and (d)
1. (C) Dominican President Leonel Fernandez travels May
11-12 to Washington for the first time since his August 2004
inauguration. The USG and regional focus of the event is the
CAFTA free trade agreement now under consideration in the
U.S. Congress. For Fernandez, however, the visit is much
more: it is a validation of his status as the democratically
elected leader of the Dominican Republic. Fernandez has told
the Ambassador repeatedly that he could not afford to go to
Washington without calling on President Bush; if he were not
received by the U.S. President on his first visit, Dominican
commentators and politicians would construe any Washington
visit as a personal snub and a failure of his administration.
Following is background and a suggested approach for several
topics that could be discussed during the trip, depending on
the final Fernandez schedule. They include CAFTA,
corruption, support for the Coalition, and the need for a
national security strategy.
ECONOMIC BACKGROUND
2. (C) Fernandez and his party have articulated a
market-friendly, socially conscious approach to domestic
politics. Fernandez is an eloquent advocate for
international cooperation and multilateralism. In the nine
months to date of his administration his economic team has
successfully put the country back into a standby agreement
with the International Monetary Fund and adhered to agreed
targets. They openly favor the CAFTA free trade agreement
and in December secured the repeal of a CAFTA-unfriendly
protectionist tax. The CAFTA is under consideration in the
Dominican Senate; powerful domestic business interests,
especially from the sugar industry, are seeking significant
fiscal concessions as a price for non-opposition to the
agreement. At the same time, the Dominican letter of
agreement with the IMF specifies that the government will put
forward proposals for fundamental tax reform this year to
offset significant revenue losses that will occur pursuant
CAFTA and WTO commitments to ending many levies on imported
goods. Dominican legislators would prefer to wait until
after the mid-2006 congressional elections to consider fiscal
reform.
ACTIVE ENGAGEMENT IN CAFTA RATIFICATION
– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
3. (C) President Fernandez is eloquent in public
pronouncements about globalization and free trade, and he has
endorsed CAFTA in general terms. He has not engaged
legislators or business interests personally on the subject
or sought to broker a practical agreement that would end the
debate about ratification. His passivity is of great concern,
for influential business interests assert that lawmakers must
grant them extensive tax concession BEFORE ratifying CAFTA.
The Dominican Senate is controlled by the opposition PRD.
Congressional elections for all seats in both houses are
scheduled for May 2006.
CAFTA APPROACH:
– – The Dominican people and legislature need their President
to engage actively in the CAFTA ratification process.
– – You have spoken eloquently about globalization and free
trade. With your 57 percent mandate in the presidential
election, you have the moral authority to pursue passage of
CAFTA.
– – The obligations of CAFTA require a major tax reform, a
fact your government acknowledged in negotiations with the
IMF. You personally and your team need to engage now to
articulate these reforms and pursue them.
CORRUPTION
– – – – –
4. (C) Fernandez says he is deeply concerned by levels of
corruption in the country. The Dominican public and press
are discussing the corruption revealed over the last two
years, including, most prominently, the "Baninter" bank fraud
and related embezzlements at Bancredito and Banco Mercantil
that collectively cost 20 percent of GDP in 2003; narcotics
trafficking and payoffs; government procurement scandals
affecting the previous administration and both of Fernandez’s
administrations. Fernandez has appointed men of integrity to
key law enforcement positions. USAID is providing him help to
mount an anti-corruption/ethics in government mechanism and
campaign. On May 2, responding to the urgings of the U.S.
ambassador, President Fernandez he belatedly and without
comment relieved his intelligence chief and two other senior
officers known to be corrupt. The government is preparing
several pieces of legislation to assure greater transparency
and to prevent opporunities for corruption.
CORRUPTION APPROACH:
– – We greatly admire your Attorney General Francisco
Dominguez Brito and several other key law enforcement
officials in your administration.
– – The USG will continue to support you in your stand
against corruption.
– – CAFTA and new Dominican legislation will provide stronger
safeguards.
– – The public must see your government act strongly and
impartially against those suspected of fraud and corruption.
SUPPORT FOR IRAQ- – – – – – – –
5. (C) Fernandez did not criticize his predecessor’s dispatch
of a 300-soldier batallion to Iraq and never commented
publicly on Operation Iraqi Freedom. The Dominican Armed
Forces Minister, acting on his understanding that he has
authorization from the President, is in the process of
selecting a limited number of Dominican staff officers,
perhaps 15-20, for duty with the U.S. Central Command and in
the Iraq area of operations. The Dominican government has
not formally notified the United States of this decision and
it has not been publicized. Selection and testing is under
way; first deployments could occur in June.
APPROACH ON IRAQ SUPPORT:
– – I understand that you have given your Armed Forces
Minister authorization to select a number of staff officers
to support the coalition efforts to protect and rebuild Iraq.
– – The Iraqi people and authorities will appreciate this
support. So do we.
– – We appreciate the quality of Dominican military
professionals; this will further qualify those officers to
participate in multilateral operations with the UN or the
Organization of American States.
NATIONAL SECURITY STRATEGY-
6. (C). President Fernandez has expressed great interest in
drawing up a national security strategy. Senior military
officers have not begun this work in earnest, devoting their
attention instead to a "White Paper" on the military instead,
and have not been receptive to Fernandez’s military advisor.
The U.S. Embassy’s Military Advisory and Assistance Group
can assist in drawing up a national strategy.
SECURITY STRATEGY APPROACH:
– – The President bears the responsibility for defining the
National Security Strategy of a nation, giving guidelines to
the government and armed forces.
– – I encourage you to take a direct interest in this work,
to constitute a working group headed by your personal
representatives with a mandate from you, and to insist on a
concerted effort.
– – A clear vision of security threats, requirements, and
resources is vital to assuming your responsibilities toward
your own population and toward the community of nations.
HERTELL
167592 27 de agosto, 2008
S E C R E T SANTO DOMINGO 001353
NOFORN
SIPDIS
STATE FOR WHA/CAR AND INR
E.O. 12958: DECL: 08/26/2048
TAGS: PGOV, PINR, SENV, MARR, ETRD, ECON, DR
SUBJECT: FERNANDEZ PLAYS MUSICAL CHAIRS WITH CABINET
REF: A. SANTO DOMINGO 1340
B. USDAO IIR 6 827 0228 08/08-21-2008
C. SANTO DOMINGO 1189
D. TD-314/03112-05/01-19-2005
Classified By: P. Robert Fannin, Ambassador, Reasons 1.4(b), (d)
Summary
——-
1. (C) In a series of decrees issued following his August 16
inauguration, President Fernandez shuffled his cabinet;
however, many of the officials simply moved from one ministry
to another. There was no clear public policy message sent by
the personnel moves. Rather, by keeping most of the cabinet
positions in the hands of PLD party insiders, particularly
those loyal to him personally, Fernandez appears to be
keeping an eye on party rival Danilo Medina (Ref A). The
demotion of Alejandrina German from Education to Women’s
Affairs was positive, given the corruption allegations
against her. The new Minister of Industry and Commerce,
Monchi Fadul, does not inspire much confidence. New
Ministers were also named for the Armed Forces, the
Presidency, Labor, Tourism, Education, and Youth. In the
security and intelligence services, while three potentially
seriously problematic appointments were avoided, we have
continuing concerns regarding several key officers. For
biographic information, see paras. 12-19.
Armed Forces
————
2. (C/NF) The new Minster of the Armed Forces, LTGEN Pedro
Pena Antonio, has a very favorable and positive background
with U.S. officers in military conference, professional
training in the U.S., and USDAO and security assistance
venues. He seeks constructive relationships with U.S.
officers without losing Dominican integrity and pride or
appearing as a doormat or puppet. He favors USG security
policies as being best for Dominican security as well. USDAO
assesses that of the several candidates to become Minister,
Pena was unquestionably the most favorable to U.S. interests.
This is based principally on his attempts to achieve a
semblance of security of Dominican airspace and his desire to
professionalize the Air Force (see also Ref B).
Security Services
—————–
3. (S/NF) In the security services, three potential
promotions that prompted serious U.S. concern (Ref C) did
not/not take place: Gen. Hector Medina Medina was not
appointed Minister of the Armed Forces; Gen. Rafael Bencosme
Candelier was not made Chief of Police; and RADM Jose Munoz
Moncion was not selected to be Navy Chief of Staff.
4. (S/NF) However, Post has continuing concerns regarding the
security services: The President "confirmed" Medina Medina
in his current position as the Chief of the Presidential
Military Aide’s Corps (CAM), where he will continue to have a
powerful influence on the President’s military decisions
(particularly regarding pesonnel). Munoz Moncion was
appointed as Commander of the Las Calderas Navy Base, located
in a principal region of drug trafficking activity. Host
nation asssets based at Las Calderas are the ones which
should respond to maritime drug deliveries from South
America. Maj. Gen. Manuel Florentino Florentino, an
individual with whom Post has serious concerns regarding
illegal activity (Ref D), was appointed head of the Frontier
Development Directorate, where opportunities for graft
related to the Haitian border are significant. At the
National Directorate for Intelligence, the cooperative
Director Sigfrido Pared Perez has been replaced by Maj. Gen.
Ramon Aquino Garcia, whose record is more neutral. On a
potentially more positive note, Bencosme Candelier was moved
to head the Metropolitan Transport Authority (AMET), where he
will presumably have fewer opportunities for nefarious
activities.
Industry and Commerce
———————
5. (C) In comments to the Ambassador, an American Chamber of
Commerce (AMCHAM) representative noted that the new Minister
of Industry and Commerce, Jose Ramon "Monchi" Fadul, has only
limited experience in the areas of trade and energy which
fall under his portfolio, including overseeing the
implementation of CAFTA-DR. The Embassy was not particularly
impressed with his performance in his previous position as
Labor Minister, where he seemed to be uninformed on important
issues. However, Fadul is a loyal party member, which should
give him some clout within the Administration.
Presidency
———
6. (C) As Minister of the Presidency, Cesar Pina Toribio will
fulfill a role similar to Chief of Staff in the U.S. system.
USAID worked with Pina in his previous positions, and
describes him as an ally of U.S. programming for the justice
sector. He has played a key role in the implementation of
the criminal procedures code. Some analysts portrayed
Fernandez’s choice of Pina as one designed to avoid having at
his right hand a person who himself aspires to the presidency.
Labor
—–
7. (C) The new Minister of Labor, Maximiliano Puig Miller, is
the leader of the leftist Alliance for Democracy Party and
the only non-PLD party member in the new cabinet. Puig was
dropped from his position as Minister of Environment in 2007
after making public allegations of corruption against the
Senate. He is expected to play an important role not only in
implementing the labor provisions of CAFTA-DR, but also in
the running of the new state-run health care system. In
comments to the Ambassador, an AMCHAM representative
described Puig as a better officer than his predecessor, the
new Minister of Industry and Commerce Fadul.
Tourism
——-
8. (C) Minister of Tourism Francisco Javier Garcia Fernandez,
another political loyalist, is being rewarded for his role as
campaign manager for the President’s re-election campaign.
Minister of Tourism is seen by many Dominicans to be a
lucrative position. During his time as Minister of Industry
and Commerce, Garcia supported transportation interests that
opposed a U.S. company’s right to implement new contracts,
which almost derailed the entry into force of CAFTA-DR. An
AMCHAM representative told the Ambassador that he was not
particularly impressed with Garcia’s prior service in the
Industry and Commerce Ministry.
Education
———
9. (C) Minister of Education Melanio Paredes has extensive
experience in the education sector, having taught at two
Universities in Santo Domingo (UNIBE and UTESA). During his
time as a congressman (1990-1994) he was chairman of the
Education Committee, and earlier he served as the General
Secretary of the Labor Union for teachers. In his previous
position as Minister of Industry and Commerce, the Embassy
found him to be an easy going person who is open, accessible,
and responsive. Post is pleased to see his predecessor,
Alejandrina German, gone from the ministry. She was the
subject of multiple corruption allegations, including a case
involving a company tied to her daughter which allegedly sold
millions of dollars worth of nutritionally deficient school
lunches to the government.
Women
—–
10. (SBU) Alejandrina German was demoted, but remains in the
cabinet as Minister of Women’s Affairs. During the first
part of her term at the Education Ministry, German’s
relationship with USAID was challenging. Over time these
challenges turned into opportunities and the relationship
improved significantly. German was eventually responsive to
our request for coordination and recognized USAID as an
important partner. She has been an advocate in expanding
USAID’s Regional Centers of Education for Teacher Training
and has committed the Ministry’s own resources in the
expansion.
Youth
—–
11. (U) The new Minister of Youth, Franklin Rodriguez, is a
lawyer and journalist. Born in 1979, he is an alumnus of the
State Department-sponsored National Democracy Institute
Leadership Program. Mr. Rodriguez is the youngest member of
the Central Committee of the PLD and was the coordinator of
the PLD youth campaign. He has also served as vice-president
of the Dominican Student Federation.
Biographic Information
———————-
12. (S/NF) Minister of Armed Forces Maj. Gen. Pedro Rafael
PENA Antonio
– Air Force Chief of Staff (2006-2008)
– Described as intelligent and outspoken, as well as pro-U.S.
and friendly with U.S. officials
– Helicopter pilot with search and rescue experience;
personal pilot to President in Fernandez’s first term
– Prior service as Assistant Military Attache in Washington,
Air Force Comptroller, Inspector General, and Vice Chief of
Staff
– Degree in human resources management
13. (U) Minister of Industry and Commerce Jose Ramon "Monchi"
FADUL
– Minister of Labor (2004-2008)
– Member of the PLD’s Political Committee
– Influential in Santiago, where he was mayor (1990-1994) and
congressional representative (1982-1986, 1994-2002)
– Former Director of the Dominican Corporation of State
Enterprises
14. (U) Minister of Presidency Cesar PINA Toribio
– Presidential Legal Adviser (1996-1999 and 2004-2008)
– Attorney General (1999-2000)
– Member of his family’s law firm since receiving his
doctorate from UASD in 1970
– Taught law at PUCMM, UNIBE, and UASD, focusing primarily on
criminal law and criminal procedure
– Member of the PLD Party’s Central Committee
15. (U) Minister of Labor Maximiliano PUIG Miller
– Minister of Environment (2004-2007)
– National Coordinator for the Lome IV Accord, with rank of
Minister (1996-2000)
– Served as Senator (1990-1994), at first with PLD, then when
that party suffered split in 1992, Puig and ten deputies
resigned from PLD to set up ADP party (ADP was in coalition
with PLD in 2008 election and prior).
– Studied sociology and public law at the University of Paris
and received his PhD in Political Science there in 1970
– Taught sociology at UASD (1971-1992)
16. (U) Minister of Tourism Francisco Javier GARCIA Fernandez
– National Campaign Manager for Leonel Fernandez for
President (2007-2008)
– Minister of Industry and Commerce (2004-2007)
– During the first Fernandez administration (1996-2000)
served as general manager for national lottery, president of
state-owned oil refinery, and executive director of port
authority
– Member of the Central and Political Committees of the PLD
– In private sector, worked as real estate developer
17. (U) Minister of Education Melanio A. PAREDES Pinales
– Minister of Industry and Commerce (2007-2008)
– Director General, National Institute for Technical and
Professional Training (2004-2007)
– Executive Director for Airports (1999)
– Professor, UNIBE and UTESA
– Congressman for San Cristobal (1990-1994)
– Physics degree, UASD
18. (U) Minister of Women’s Affairs Alejandrina GERMAN
– Minister of Education (2004-2008)
– Minister of Presidency (1999-2000)
– Director, Higher Education Council (1996-2000)
– Member of PLD party Political Committee
19. (U) Minister of Youth Franklin RODRIGUEZ
– President, PLD party youth wing
– Alumnus of the State Department sponsored National
Democracy Institute Leadership Program
– Member of Central Committee of PLD
– Former vice-president of Dominican Student Federation (FED)
– Born 1979 in San Cristobal
(U) Please visit us at
http://www.state.sgov.gov/p/wha/santodomingo/
FANNIN